Are you kidding me? Microsoft just launched a website to help users decide between buying a new PC running Windows 7 and buying a Mac. I realize I shouldn’t expect an impartial comparison of the two systems from the same people that brought you Vista, but the reasons they give are just ridiculous. Full disclosure, I’ve been a Mac user for almost two years now, but I have plenty of experience with Windows, from 98 all the way through to 7. Don’t get me wrong, there are plenty of reasons to buy a Windows PC rather than a Mac. A few of those reasons are even listed on this site:
1) If you’re a gamer… buy a PC!
2) Apple insists on using their own adapters and connectors for everything. So be prepared to have cables that don’t fit.
3) Security through obscurity. Apple’s much smaller market share has protected it from the fury of the hacker community. As the market share rises, so will the number of viruses.
4) Some specialized programs are only available for Windows. Usually, you can find a Mac alternative, but sometimes the only solution is VMWare Fusion… and general slowwwwness.
As for the rest of the reasons they give… well, they’re just silly!
1) Macs can take time to learn.
Really? That’s your argument? Sure, Macs take time to learn… so does Vista! So does my new Camcorder! So did my Combi-Oven! Is that the reason we should never use newer or better technologies? Because they “can take time to learn”? And where is the evidence that learning Mac takes longer than learning Windows 7? Are they basing this on users that have never used either platform or are they assuming (and yes they are) that these users have used XP and Vista for years, so they are already used to the idea of a Start Menu… and a Blue Screen!
“Things just don’t work the same way on Macs if you’re used to a PC…” goes the argumentation. Again, really? You know, things don’t work the same way with a Microwave if you’re used to a convection oven! Ergo, don’t buy a Microwave! Things don’t work the same way on a DVD player if you’re used to VHS! So, don’t buy a DVD player either!
And another thing, the way this whole site is presented, they make the reader think that buying a PC running Windows 7 will allow them all these extra features, like DVR, Touch screens, fingerprint readers and much, much more, without specifying that this depends on the hardware… and price of the machine. An entry level PC won’t support these features, so why mention them? Maybe an advanced user knows the difference and will buy the more expensive, specialized hardware, but then this website reads as if it’s targeted at 3rd graders and grannies, so my guess is they wouldn’t know how to configure a DVR or notice the difference between a DVD or BlueRay film on their 15” display.
2) Macs don’t work as well at work or at school.
What? Is that why 70 percent of college freshmen are choosing a Mac over a PC? And my Mac is my work PC! Sharing documents? Just save your documents in the .doc format or (like I did) install MS Office for the Mac.
3) Macs don’t like to share.
What! Mac has the easiest sharing possibilities ever! Mac has a Sharing Preference Pane where you can choose to share using any of an assortment of protocols, such as FTP, SSH, SMB, AFP, BlueTooth, sharing your screen, your internet connection, etc. just with a click of a button! Does windows have remote login via SSH or an integrated FTP server… survey says NO! And I just love this. They are bragging about the fact that you have to manually turn on sharing on a Mac, but with Windows 7, it’s automatically on… Well, I would contend on Windows you have to manually disable sharing, but on a Mac it’s automatically off.
4) Macs might not like your PC stuff.
Again, Windows won’t open iWork formats. I had the idea that this had already been mentioned, but whatever. Solution: MS Office could offer compatibility (yeah right!) or Mac users can save their files in .doc format or… the best option… just install MS Office for Mac.
5) Macs don’t let you choose.
Seems like a rather harsh blanket statement… but in some regards, I completely agree. The basic Apple philosophy is “We looked at all the options and preselected the best choice for our users.” There is very limited hardware diversity and most programs offer very little customization. This is true. But the streamlined hardware and lack of legacy support allows Macs to be much faster and much, much, much more stable than their PC counterparts. Oh, and I’m not exaggerating. You know those Blue Screen of Death and Ctrl+Alt+Del jokes… yeah, with a Mac you don’t have that. None of that rebooting nonsense and none of those “my computer crashed” silliness. Apple controls the hardware and software with an iron fist. An iron fist that produces amazing results, that is! Limited choice is apparently the price we pay for having fast, stable machines.
